The Church
has consistently condemned doctrinaire laissez-faire
forms of capitalism and insisted on just wages, moderate state intervention in
the economy, and the grave duty of the rich to assist the poor. Everyone knows these things because they are
frequently talked about, and rightly so.
But the Church has also consistently and vigorously opposed socialism in
all its forms and all left-wing revolutionary movements, for reasons grounded
in natural law and Christian moral theology.
This is less frequently talked about, but especially important today,
when much of what is being done or called for in the name of justice is in fact
gravely immoral.
Tuesday, June 30, 2020
Thursday, June 25, 2020
ACPQ symposium on Aristotle’s Revenge
The American
Catholic Philosophical Association meeting in Minneapolis last November hosted
an Author Meets Critics session on my book Aristotle’s
Revenge: The Metaphysical Foundations of Physical and Biological Science. The proceedings have now been published in the
Summer 2020 issue of the American
Catholic Philosophical Quarterly. In
the first
essay I provide a précis of the book.
In the second
essay, philosopher Robert Koons addresses what I say in the book about the
A-theory and B-theory of time, and argues that the latter is easier to
reconcile with an Aristotelian philosophy of nature than I suggest. In the third
essay, physicist Stephen Barr puts forward some criticisms of my views
about method, space, and substantial form.
In the final
essay, I respond to Koons and Barr.
Monday, June 22, 2020
Envy cancels justice
Envy is
often mistaken for anger at injustice, because both can issue in hatred. But the hatred that issues from a desire for justice
is righteous, whereas the hatred that issues from envy is wicked. How can we know the difference? One telltale sign is the object of one’s hatred. Is
it what a person does? Or the person himself? Aquinas writes:
It is lawful to hate the sin in one's
brother, and whatever pertains to the defect of Divine justice, but we cannot hate
our brother's nature and grace without sin.
Now it is part of our love for our brother that we hate the fault and
the lack of good in him, since desire for another’s good is equivalent to
hatred of his evil. Consequently the
hatred of one's brother, if we consider it simply, is always sinful.
(Summa theologiae II-II.34.3)
Wednesday, June 17, 2020
Apt pupil
Justice Neil
Gorsuch was a student of John Finnis, foremost proponent of the “New Natural
Law Theory” (NNLT). Is that relevant to
understanding the Bostock decision? It might seem not, given that NNLT thinkers
like Robbie George (here
and here)
and Ryan
Anderson have strongly criticized Gorsuch’s reasoning.
Saturday, June 13, 2020
Locke’s “transubstantiation” of the self
Locke’s
agnosticism about substance led him to treat the self as essentially a bundle
of attributes. Given his empiricism, he
takes it that the most we can say of a substance – whether material or
immaterial – is that it is a “something, I know not what” that underlies
attributes. And that is too thin a conception
to lend confidence to the thesis that the self qua substance can survive death
and be rewarded or punished in the afterlife.
What to do? Locke’s solution was
to ignore substance as beside the point.
What matters for Locke is that one’s consciousness,
and in particular one’s memories, can carry over after the death of the body,
whether or not there is a soul for them to inhere in.
Friday, June 12, 2020
Great minds on wokeness
If you want
to understand woke totalitarianism, I recommend reading Plato on democracy,
Aristotle and Aquinas on envy, and Nietzsche on ressentiment.
Or you could
just watch a few minutes of John Cleese,
Seinfeld, South Park, and Family Guy. (But do it soon, before it’s all removed.)
Wednesday, June 10, 2020
Theology and the analytic a posteriori
Philosophers
traditionally distinguish between analytic
and synthetic propositions. An analytic proposition is one that is true
or false by virtue of the relations between its constituent concepts. A stock example is “All bachelors are
unmarried,” which is true because the concept of being unmarried is included in
the concept of being a bachelor. A
synthetic proposition is true by virtue of something beyond the relations
between its constituent concepts. For
example, the proposition “Some bachelors are lonely” is true by virtue of a
contingent empirical relation between being a bachelor and being lonely, rather
than a necessary conceptual relation between them.
Saturday, June 6, 2020
Pod people
With woke fanatics
suddenly overrunning The New York
Times, the public health
profession, peaceful
protests, and even the
knitting community (!), life in these United States is starting to look a
little like the 1978 sci-fi classic Invasion
of the Body Snatchers. If you’re
looking for something timely to watch this evening, I recommend it. (It’s a great flick anyway.)
The metaphor
is near perfect. People are transformed
into robotic pod people only after first falling asleep and (get this) waking up. One moment they’re polite fellow citizens,
the next they are all gaping maws, shrieking at you so as to summon the rest of
the mob over for reeducation or a beat down.
After their transformation, even longtime friends and loved ones
suddenly turn on you. And in a nice
touch, much of the focus of the movie is on the pod people’s commandeering of…
the local health department.
If you want
to turn it into film festival, next rent The Last Emperor
and check out its chilling portrayal of the Maoist Red Guard. (Some of our wokesters have apparently seen
it, and thought it a “How to” video.)
And then, to
see where this mentality leads if unchecked, The
Killing Fields.
Wednesday, June 3, 2020
What “the science” is saying this week (Updated)
Andrew
Sullivan calls
our attention to epidemiologist Tara C. Smith, who moves with that curious herd
of “experts” suddenly not terribly concerned about social distancing when the
protesters filling the streets are left-wing rather than right-wing. Writes Sullivan: “The message to normies:
going outside is killing grandma. The message to woke kids: never mind!”
So which is
it? Were people like Smith lying before about
the danger of spreading the virus, in order to promote a political agenda? Or being honest about it but now willing to endanger
countless lives, in order to promote a political agenda?
Friday, May 29, 2020
Metaphysical taxidermy
I’ve often
emphasized that the reason consciousness poses such a persistent problem for
materialism has less to do with consciousness itself than it has to do with the
desiccated conception of matter that we’ve inherited from early modern
philosophy and science. Barry Dainton
makes the same point a couple of times in his book Self. For example, he writes:
Friday, May 22, 2020
The lockdown is no longer morally justifiable
As
I have said before, I think that the lockdown that was put in place in the United States
two months ago was morally justifiable given the circumstances at the
time. In my opinion, under current
circumstances, it is no longer morally justifiable. To be sure, I am not denying that some social distancing measures are still justifiable and even necessary. I am also not denying that a more modest
lockdown may still be defensible in some localities. But the draconian total lockdown that was put in place across most of the country is
at this point no longer defensible, and state and local authorities who are
relaxing it are right to do so.
Thursday, May 21, 2020
Oderberg on the hierarchy of being
In February,
David Oderberg gave a lecture in Oxford on the theme “Recovering
the Hierarchy of Being.” You can now watch it on
YouTube. Be sure also to check out David’s new book The
Metaphysics of Good and Evil (about which you can find information at
the publisher’s website).
Friday, May 15, 2020
The lockdown and appeals to authority
Here are two
things every serious student of logical fallacies understands. First, if what is at issue is the soundness of an argument, then the
motives and expertise of the person giving the argument are completely irrelevant. To fail to see this is to commit an ad hominem fallacy of “poisoning the
well.” Second, if what is at issue is
the credibility of expert testimony, then
the motives and expertise of the
person giving the testimony are highly
relevant. To fail to see this is to
commit a fallacy of “appeal to authority.”
Friday, May 8, 2020
Presentism and analogical language
Terms are
used univocally when they are used in
the same sense, as the word “bat” is in both “The baseball player swung the bat”
and “The cricket player swung the bat.”
Terms are used equivocally
when why are used in completely unrelated senses, as the term “bat” is in “The
baseball player swung the bat” and “A bat flew in through Bruce Wayne’s
window.” The analogical use of terms is a middle ground kind of usage. I gave an example when discussing Aristotelian
realism in my recent First Things review of William
Lane Craig’s book God Over All:
Friday, May 1, 2020
Joe Biden Superstar
For
something lighter as you go into the weekend, have a listen to songstress
Hannah Hoffman’s “You
Know the Thing,” a setting to music of Joe Biden’s deep thoughts on the
foundations of human rights. This promises
to become something of a new genre, given that we’ve already had The Gregory
Brothers’ now-classic Biden-penned hit “Hairy Legs.” Certainly you can take it to the bank that
Biden will keep providing us with interesting lyrics.
While you’re
at it, you should check out also the jazzy Ms. Hoffman’s philosophical tunes “Euthyphro,” “Fallacy
Funk,” and “The
Trolley Problem.”
Thursday, April 30, 2020
The burden of proof is on those who impose burdens (Updated)
I have argued
both that the
lockdown was a justifiable initial reaction to the Covid-19 crisis,
and that skeptics
ought nevertheless to be listened to, and listened to more earnestly
the longer the lockdown goes on. Here’s
one front line doctor who argues that it has gone on long enough and
should be eased up. Is he right? Maybe, though I don’t have the expertise to
answer with certainty, and I’m not addressing that question here anyway. What I am sure of is this much: The burden of
proof is not in the first place on him and people of like mind to show that the
lockdown should be ended. The burden is
on defenders of the lockdown to show
that it shouldn’t be.
Thursday, April 23, 2020
Links for the lockdown
Thomas
Osborne’s new book Aquinas’s Ethics,
part of the Cambridge Elements series, is
available online for free for a month.
How should a
Thomist deal with a pandemic? Robert Koons
proposes some
general principles, at Public
Discourse.
At Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews, Thomas
Nagel reviews
Richard Swinburne’s Are We Bodies or
Souls?
Sunday, April 19, 2020
Kremer on classical theism
At YouTube, philosopher
Elmar Kremer provides a useful multi-part introduction to the dispute between
classical theism and theistic personalism, as part of the Wireless Philosophy video
series. Here are links to each of the installments:
Thursday, April 16, 2020
The lockdown’s loyal opposition
At First Things, Fr. Thomas Joseph White has
defended the Covid-19 lockdown, whereas Rusty Reno has
criticized it. As I
said last week, I agree with Fr. Thomas Joseph but I also believe
that reason, charity, and the common good require serious engagement with
skeptics like Rusty – and that this is more
true, rather than less, the longer the lockdown goes on. Meanwhile, at The Bulwark, conservative lockdown defender Jonathan V. Last tells
us that he won’t link even to Fr. Thomas Joseph’s article, let alone
Rusty’s. The reason is that Fr. Thomas
Joseph’s article “made matters worse, not better” by granting “legitimacy” to
the idea that “there are really two sides to the issue, and that reasonable and
intelligent people can disagree.” He
compares Rusty’s skepticism to that of flat-earthers and anti-vaxxers.
Tuesday, April 14, 2020
Review of Scientism
My brief review of the anthology
Scientism: Prospects and Problems,
edited by Jeroen de Ridder, Rik Peels,
and René van Woudenberg, appears in the December 2019 issue of Review of Metaphysics. (The preview you see in that link leaves out
only the last paragraph and a half or so of the review.)
Sunday, April 12, 2020
The lesson of the Resurrection
The lesson
of the Resurrection is that the significance of our bodily life and its
sufferings should be neither overstated nor understated. It is to see the middle ground between
materialism and Platonism. In our decadent
sensualist age, the anti-materialist message is perhaps the more obvious one. The secularist can see no fate worse than unfulfilled
earthly ambitions, unhappy marriages, unpaid bills, poor health, and the
deathbed. And no greater good than the
avoidance of such things. Woody Allen
captures the mindset well: “Life is full of misery, loneliness, and suffering –
and it’s all over much too soon.”
Friday, April 10, 2020
Some thoughts on the COVID-19 crisis
I commend to
you Fr. Thomas Joseph White’s First
Things essay on the
COVID-19 situation and the bishops’ response to it. It exhibits his characteristic good sense and
charity. First Things editor Rusty Reno, with whom Fr. Thomas Joseph
disagrees, exhibits his characteristic magnanimity and intellectual honesty in
running it. My sympathies are with Fr.
Thomas Joseph’s views rather than Rusty’s, but I have been appalled by the nastiness
of others who have responded to Rusty (who is a good man and a serious thinker
and writer who deserves to be engaged with seriously). Our situation calls for patience with one
another and the calm exchange of opposing views, for the sake of the common
good. Too many have instead treated the
debate over COVID-19 as an extension of hostilities that pre-existed the
crisis. This is gravely contrary to reason
and charity.
Tuesday, April 7, 2020
Damnation denialism
Here’s a
narrative we’re all by now familiar with.
Call it Narrative A:
Those who initially downplayed the
dangers of COVID-19 were guilty of wishful thinking, as are those who think the
crisis can be resolved either easily or soon.
This is what the experts tell us, and we should listen to them. Even though those most at risk of death from
the novel coronavirus are the elderly and those with preexisting medical
conditions, this is a large group. Moreover,
many people who won’t die from the virus will still suffer greatly, and even
those with mild symptoms or none at all can still infect others. Draconian measures are called for, even at
the risk of massive unemployment, the undoing of people’s retirement plans, and
the depletion of their savings. Better
safe than sorry. To resist these hard
truths is to be guilty of “coronavirus denialism.”
Monday, March 30, 2020
Franklin on Aristotelian realism and mathematics
At YouTube,
mathematician and philosopher James Franklin, author of An
Aristotelian Realist Philosophy of Mathematics, offers a brief introduction to the
subject. Also check out the website he
and some others have devoted to Aristotelian realism, as well as Franklin’s personal website.
A public lecture on
mathematics and ethics that Franklin is scheduled to give on April 2 will,
in light of the COVID-19 situation, be pre-recorded and posted online.
Saturday, March 28, 2020
Craig, conventionalism, and voluntarism
For our philosophically inclined
readers who are interested in divine aseity and Platonism, here's a great little
philosophical exercise: Where does this review by Ed Feser go wrong? (Hint: do
I hold that mathematical truth is conventional? Why think I should?)
Tuesday, March 24, 2020
Aquinas anticipated everything
So notes a friend who sent me this image of the cover of a dissertation
from the 1950s. (No doubt the author was
using the phrase in a different sense than has now become familiar. Any guesses as to the true subject matter?)
Friday, March 20, 2020
Craig contra the truthmaker objection to presentism
Presentism
holds that, in the temporal realm (that is to say, apart from eternal and
aeviternal entities), only present objects and events exist. Now, if statements about past events and
objects are true, then there must be something that makes them true. But in that case, the “truthmaker objection”
to presentism holds, past objects and events must exist. I’ve argued in previous
posts that this objection is greatly overrated. Indeed, for the reasons I gave there, I can’t
myself fathom what all the fuss is about.
William Lane Craig seems to agree.
In his book God
Over All (which I reviewed recently in First Things), he has
occasion briefly to address the issue. Craig
writes:
Sunday, March 15, 2020
Coronavirus complications
For reasons
most of which have to do directly or indirectly with the COVID-19 coronavirus
situation, none of the remaining public lectures for the first half or so of
the year that I had announced a couple of months ago will occur. (There are still events planned for the
latter half of the year, which I will announce closer to the time.)
Also, in
light of the situation, my college, like many others, has abruptly transitioned
to online teaching. The resulting new workload
promises to be as heavy as it was sudden and unexpected.
I fully
intend to keep this blog going to doomsday and beyond, but if things
temporarily get a little slower here in the next couple of weeks as I adjust to
this new reality, that is why!
Wednesday, March 11, 2020
Review of Craig’s God Over All
My review of
William Lane Craig’s book God
Over All: Divine Aseity and the Challenge of Platonism appears in the
April 2020 issue of First Things. You can read it
online here.
Sunday, March 8, 2020
On-topic open thread (and a word on trolls)
Folks,
please don’t post off-topic
comments in the comboxes. I will delete
them, and any responses to them, as soon as I see them, and (since I don’t always see them immediately) sometimes
that means that a long thread will develop that is destined to end up in the
ether. Remember, if your comment begins
with something like “This is off topic, but…,” then it isn’t a comment you should
be posting. And remember too, there is
always that remedy for concupiscence known as the open thread. Here’s the latest. This time, everything is on topic, from acid jazz
to Thomas Szasz, from Family Guy to Strong
AI, from the coronavirus to Miley Cyrus.
Tuesday, March 3, 2020
The other way to lose a war
Rod Dreher comments
on the U.S. deal with the Taliban to withdraw, at long last, from
Afghanistan. He writes: “The Taliban
whipped… the United States… We simply could not prevail. The richest and
most powerful nation in the world could not beat these SOBs.” Well, that’s obviously not true in the usual
sense of words like “whipped” and “beat.”
Suppose you effortlessly beat me to a bloody pulp and I fall to the
ground, desperately panting for air and barely conscious. You put your boot on my neck and demand that
I cry “Uncle.” I refuse, despite your
repeated kicks to the gut, and after fifteen minutes or so of this you get
bored and walk away. It would be quite
absurd if, wiping the blood off my face and pulling myself up to my wobbling
knees, I proudly exclaim: “Did you see how I whipped that guy?”
Thursday, February 27, 2020
Agere sequitur esse and the First Way
Aquinas’s
First Way is also known as the argument from motion to an Unmoved Mover. The most natural way to read it is as an
argument to the effect that things could not change at any given moment if there were no divine cause keeping
the change going. But some Thomists have
read it instead as an argument to the effect that changing things could not
even exist at any given moment if
there were no divine cause keeping them in being. That’s the reading I propose in my book Aquinas
and my ACPQ article “Existential
Inertia and the Five Ways,” and it’s a line of argument I develop
and defend in greater depth in chapter 1 of Five
Proofs of the Existence of God.
Friday, February 21, 2020
Morgan on Aristotle’s Revenge
At The Imaginative Conservative, Prof. Jason
Morgan kindly
reviews my book Aristotle’s
Revenge. From the review:
In 456 very well-written pages…
(followed by a treasure trove of a bibliography), Dr. Feser shows in Aristotle’s
Revenge that, point for point, Aristotle got science
right, or as right as he could given the limitations in instrumentation and
communication with other researchers during his time. Scientists since the so-called Enlightenment
have been trying to detach Aristotle’s greatest insight, the telos of things, from the world around them. But the telos is the linchpin of the material
world, so without it, everything, as is apparent from most philosophy lectures
one attends nowadays, or nearly any philosophy book one reads, falls apart…
Saturday, February 15, 2020
The socialist state as an occasionalist god
Hobbes
famously characterized his Leviathan state as a mortal god. Here’s another theological analogy, or set of
analogies, which might illuminate the differences between kinds of political and economic orders – and in particular, the differences between socialism, libertarianism,
and the middle ground natural law understanding of the state.
Recall that
there are three general accounts of divine causality vis-à-vis the created
order: occasionalism, mere conservationism, and concurrentism (to borrow Fred
Freddoso’s classification).
Saturday, February 8, 2020
Sandstad and Jansen on Aristotle’s Revenge
At the Bryn Mawr Classical Review,
philosophers Petter Sandstad and Ludger Jansen review my book Aristotle’s
Revenge. From the review:
Feser’s
book adds to a growing body of literature on neo-Aristotelian approaches in
metaphysics and the philosophy of science.
However, Feser stands out from other analytic neo-Aristotelians with his
in-depth knowledge and discussion of 20th and 21st century
neo-Thomistic literature, and one can learn a lot from reading this book…
Thursday, February 6, 2020
Discussion with Graham Oppy
Earlier today on Cameron Bertuzzi’s Capturing Christianity program,
I had a very pleasant and fruitful live exchange with Graham Oppy. You can watch it on YouTube. This is the second exchange Oppy and I have
had on the show. The first was last
July, and you can still watch
that on YouTube as well. In that earlier
exchange we discussed my book Five
Proofs of the Existence of God. The
book comes up in the latest exchange as well, as does Oppy’s Religious Studies article “On
stage one of Feser’s ‘Aristotelian proof.’”
Tuesday, February 4, 2020
Review of Kerr
My review of
Gaven Kerr’s excellent book Aquinas's
Way to God: The Proof in De Ente et Essentia appears in the current issue of The Thomist (Vol.
83, No. 2).
Friday, January 31, 2020
Preternatural theology
Natural theology is traditionally distinguished from revealed theology. Natural theology is concerned with knowledge
about God’s existence and nature that is available to us via the use of our
natural cognitive faculties, such as by
way of philosophical arguments. It
does not require an appeal to any special divine revelation, whether embodied
in scripture, the teachings of a prophet backed by miracles, or what have you. There might happen to be teachings in some
source of special divine revelation that overlap with the deliverances of
natural theology, but what makes something a matter of natural theology is that
it can at least in principle be known apart from that.
Thursday, January 23, 2020
Adventures in the Old Atheism, Part IV: Marx
I have never
been remotely attracted to Marxism. Its
economic reductionism, vision of human life as a struggle of antagonistic
classes, hostility to the family, and the hermeneutics of suspicion enshrined
in its theory of ideology, are all repulsive and inhuman. Other elements, such as the theory of surplus
value and prophecies about the withering away of the state and the idyll of
life under communism, are sheer tosh. These
flaws are grave and real whatever one thinks about capitalism. Indeed, opposition to Marxism is in my view a
prerequisite to being a serious critic of capitalism, for Marxism contains none
of the good that is in capitalism, much of the bad that is in it, and adds
grave evils of its own to boot.
Tuesday, January 21, 2020
Aquinas 101
The Thomistic
Institute has added to the great work it is already doing by introducing Aquinas 101, “a series of
free video courses… that help you to engage life’s most urgent philosophical
and theological questions with the wisdom of St. Thomas Aquinas.” Here are four brief and lucid examples: Fr.
Dominic Legge on the
problem of evil, Fr. James Brent on the
principle of non-contradiction, Fr. Thomas Joseph White on the
abiding relevance of Aquinas, and Fr. Gregory Maria Pine on how to read the Summa Theologiae. Check
them out and enroll today!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


































