Addison confesses an interest in my “motives” for criticizing his brother’s views. Well, that’s easy to explain. People have been asking me to comment on David’s article ever since it appeared. David is a very prominent figure in Christian theology, and the position he defends is, in my view and that of many other Christians, seriously misguided. So, I judged it worthwhile to respond to him. The fact that I had recently written up a series of posts on the doctrine of hell made it a fitting time to do so. And there you have it.
UPDATE 1/13: In the combox below, Addison Hart and David Hart respond, and I reply to their responses.