Saturday, April 30, 2022
Crito, was out of loyalty to the country of which he was so critical, and which willed to destroy him. I don’t think that Socrates’ example is, in this case, one that we are bound to follow; Aristotle did no wrong in fleeing, lest Athens sin twice against philosophy. All the same, that example is worth pondering for contemporary conservatives tempted to oikophobia by the sorry state of the West, and for Catholics tempted by the sorry state of the Church’s human element to depart from her, or to refuse due submission to the Roman Pontiff.
Posted by Edward Feser at 12:37 PM 96 comments:
Monday, April 25, 2022
Fr. Gregory Pine on prudence
Posted by Edward Feser at 4:01 PM 21 comments:
Friday, April 22, 2022
Whose pantheism? Which dualism? A Reply to David Bentley Hart
Over at Substack, David Bentley Hart has written an open letter in reply to my recent review, at Public Discourse, of his book You Are Gods: On Nature and Supernature. What follows is my own open letter in response. Before reading it, it would help if you’ve already read my review and Hart’s reply.
Many thanks for your enjoyable and vigorous rejoinder. If your eyes fall on this, I know they will be rolling at the prospect of yet another round. But I cannot resist a reply to what seem to me basic misunderstandings, along with crucial concessions disguised as rebuttals. I do promise to refrain from Photoshop antics and cheap puns, for the sake of preserving our armistice and basic good taste. Plus, I wouldn’t want any of your readers to spill their sherry.
Posted by Edward Feser at 3:22 PM 94 comments:
Monday, April 18, 2022
Tales from the Coffin
my recent post criticizing Benevacantism, I deliberately avoided naming specific individuals, in the hope of preventing the debate from degenerating into a clash of personalities. I also said: “I make no judgment here about the culpability of those drawn to this error, many of whom are well-meaning people understandably troubled by the state of the Church and the world.” Unfortunately, not everyone is keen on keeping the discussion civil or focused on arguments and evidence.
Posted by Edward Feser at 3:29 PM 76 comments:
Tuesday, April 12, 2022
Benevacantism is scandalous and pointless
The Plato Cult and Other Philosophical Follies, David Stove observes that an argument once given by philosopher of science Imré Lakatos “manages to be scandalous and pointless at the same time” (p. 8). He was referring to Lakatos’s having made use of certain historical examples, some of the details of which Lakatos admitted he had made up himself. The idea is that, as bad as dishonest scholarship is, worse still is defeating the whole purpose by admitting that that is what you are doing. I put aside for present purposes the question of whether Stove’s characterization of Lakatos was actually fair. What I’m interested in here is the general idea of a position that is simultaneously scandalous and pointless.
Posted by Edward Feser at 12:06 AM 105 comments:
Tuesday, April 5, 2022
Two Harts beaten as one
defends his namesake David Bentley Hart against the objections I raised in my Public Discourse review of the latter Hart’s new book You Are Gods: On Nature and Supernature. What follows is a response to the former Hart’s four lines of criticism. In case you are wondering, the article informs us that there is no relation between the two Harts. To avoid confusion, I’ll mostly refer to them as “S. Hart” and “D. B. Hart” in what follows. I am, in any event, thrilled by the prospect of some new cringeworthy puns.
Posted by Edward Feser at 4:14 PM 114 comments:
Sunday, April 3, 2022
Touring the fifth circle
my very low opinion of the medium. The reason for signing up is simply to be able to see what is going on, and I don’t intend to be very active on it myself. If I ever am, I ask my family and friends to stage an intervention.
Posted by Edward Feser at 12:44 PM 30 comments:
Subscribe to: Posts (Atom)