Thursday, November 14, 2019
Graham Oppy’s article “On stage one of Feser’s ‘Aristotelian proof’”, which responds to some of the arguments I give in Five Proofs of the Existence of God, has recently been posted at the website of the journal Religious Studies. I will be writing up a response. (In the meantime, readers who have not seen it may be interested in my recent debate with Oppy on Capturing Christianity.)
In the Fall 2019 issue of Nova et Vetera, Joshua Lim kindly reviews Five Proofs. From the review:
Sunday, November 10, 2019
How bad can a bad pope get? Pretty bad. Here are two further examples from history. Marcellinus was pope from c. 296 – 304. During his pontificate, Emperor Diocletian initiated a persecution of the Christians, requiring the surrender of sacred texts and the offering of incense to the Roman gods. Marcellinus and some of his clergy apparently complied, though Marcellinus is also said to have repented of this after a few days and to have suffered martyrdom as a result. Some claim that by virtue of his compliance he was guilty of a formal apostasy that resulted in loss of the papal office, though his purported repentance and martyrdom also led to his veneration and recognition as a saint.
Thursday, November 7, 2019
Monday, November 4, 2019
The increasingly strange pontificate of Pope Francis is leading many Catholics into increasingly strange behavior. Some, like the emperor’s sycophants in the Hans Christian Anderson story, insist with ever greater shrillness that nothing Pope Francis does is ever really in the least bit problematic. If your eyes seem plainly to be telling you otherwise, then it is, they insist, your lying eyes that are the problem. Others, incapable of such self-deception, are driven into a panic by the pope’s manifestly problematic words and actions. They overreact, either beating a retreat into sedevacantism or judging that the claims of Catholicism have been proven false and that the only recourse is Eastern Orthodoxy.